← Back to player profile

Adam Cartagena vs Coal Shultis

Shared game history, mirrored head-to-head record, and full pod context.

Adam Cartagena profile Coal Shultis profile

Game filter

Shared W-L-D stats can be limited to Elo-worthy events with 30+ players; Elo rankings are unchanged.

Show 30+ player games only

Adam Cartagena Record

2-6-4

Perspective: Adam Cartagena

Coal Shultis Record

2-6-4

Perspective: Coal Shultis

Shared Games

12

Latest Meeting

Apr 1, 2026

First Meeting

Nov 1, 2025

Adam Cartagena Commander Stats

Commander	Games	W-L-D
Unknown Commander	12	2-6-4

Coal Shultis Commander Stats

Commander	Games	W-L-D
Unknown Commander	12	2-6-4

Chronological Game History

Sorted newest first. Expand a game to see the full pod and winner highlight.

CriticalEDH April 2026 League

Adam Cartagena won

Apr 1, 2026Round 1Table 1167Adam Cartagena: Seat 4, Unknown CommanderCoal Shultis: Seat 3, Unknown Commander

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	Chris Papayannes	Unknown Commander	LOSS
2

CriticalEDH February 2026 League

TumbleOP won

Feb 1, 2026Round 1Table 2499Adam Cartagena: Seat 4, Unknown CommanderCoal Shultis: Seat 2, Unknown Commander

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	TumbleOP	Unknown Commander	WINNER
2	Coal Shultis	Unknown Commander	LOSS
3	Shane Tellman	Unknown Commander	LOSS
4	Adam Cartagena	Unknown Commander	LOSS

CriticalEDH January 2026 League

Alex W won

Jan 4, 2026Round 1Table 1769Adam Cartagena: Seat 1, Unknown CommanderCoal Shultis: Seat 2, Unknown Commander

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	Adam Cartagena	Unknown Commander	LOSS
2	Coal Shultis	Unknown Commander	LOSS
3	Alex W	Gwenom, Remorseless	WINNER
4	David Garmo	Unknown Commander	LOSS

CriticalEDH January 2026 League

Draw

Jan 4, 2026Round 1Table 998Adam Cartagena: Seat 3, Unknown CommanderCoal Shultis: Seat 1, Unknown Commander

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	Coal Shultis	Unknown Commander	DRAW
2	Jonathan Howell	Unknown Commander	DRAW
3	Adam Cartagena	Unknown Commander	DRAW
4	Ed Molloy	Unknown Commander	DRAW

CriticalEDH January 2026 League

Draw

Jan 4, 2026Round 1Table 945Adam Cartagena: Seat 2, Unknown CommanderCoal Shultis: Seat 1, Unknown Commander

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	Coal Shultis	Unknown Commander	DRAW
2	Adam Cartagena	Unknown Commander	DRAW
3	minimav007	Unknown Commander	DRAW
4	Topp	Unknown Commander	DRAW

CriticalEDH January 2026 League

Coal Shultis won

Jan 4, 2026Round 1Table 1678Adam Cartagena: Seat 3, Unknown CommanderCoal Shultis: Seat 4, Unknown Commander

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	BigSpoon🥄🥄🥄🥄	Unknown Commander	LOSS
2	[A52] William Cooperman	Unknown Commander	LOSS
3	Adam Cartagena	Unknown Commander	LOSS
4	Coal Shultis	Unknown Commander	WINNER

CriticalEDH December 2025 League

Adam Cartagena won

Dec 1, 2025Round 1Table 978Adam Cartagena: Seat 1, Unknown CommanderCoal Shultis: Seat 3, Unknown Commander

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	Adam Cartagena	Unknown Commander	WINNER
2	PkPXavier	Unknown Commander	LOSS
3	Coal Shultis	Unknown Commander	LOSS
4	VarrakS \| Ban Rhystic Study	Unknown Commander	LOSS

CriticalEDH December 2025 League

Nicholas Mott (greyzel) won

Dec 1, 2025Round 1Table 898Adam Cartagena: Seat 1, Unknown CommanderCoal Shultis: Seat 2, Unknown Commander

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	Adam Cartagena	Unknown Commander	LOSS
2	Coal Shultis	Unknown Commander	LOSS
3	Woody	Unknown Commander	LOSS
4	Nicholas Mott (greyzel)	Unknown Commander	WINNER

CriticalEDH November 2025 League

Draw

Nov 1, 2025Round 1Table 258Adam Cartagena: Seat 4, Unknown CommanderCoal Shultis: Seat 1, Unknown Commander

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	Coal Shultis	Unknown Commander	DRAW
2	[PBG] AndrewRelck	Unknown Commander	DRAW
3	ThePapaSquats	Unknown Commander	DRAW
4	Adam Cartagena	Unknown Commander	DRAW

CriticalEDH November 2025 League

Draw

Nov 1, 2025Round 1Table 1873Adam Cartagena: Seat 4, Unknown CommanderCoal Shultis: Seat 1, Unknown Commander

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	Coal Shultis	Unknown Commander	DRAW
2	Ben Munroe	Unknown Commander	DRAW
3	Max P	Unknown Commander	DRAW
4	Adam Cartagena	Unknown Commander	DRAW

CriticalEDH November 2025 League

Coal Shultis won

Nov 1, 2025Round 1Table 1870Adam Cartagena: Seat 2, Unknown CommanderCoal Shultis: Seat 3, Unknown Commander

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	Kamden K	Unknown Commander	LOSS
2	Adam Cartagena	Unknown Commander	LOSS
3	Coal Shultis	Unknown Commander	WINNER
4	Cris [NEST]	Unknown Commander	LOSS

CriticalEDH November 2025 League

Christopher Gonzalez won

Nov 1, 2025Round 1Table 535Adam Cartagena: Seat 4, Unknown CommanderCoal Shultis: Seat 1, Unknown Commander

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	Coal Shultis	Unknown Commander	LOSS
2	Christopher Gonzalez	Kodama of the East Tree / Thrasios, Triton Hero	WINNER
3	Meta Mat	Unknown Commander	LOSS
4	Adam Cartagena	Unknown Commander	LOSS