← Back to player profile

Polyphemus’ Eyepatch vs Josh Zuckerman-Erd // CriticalEDH

Shared game history, mirrored head-to-head record, and full pod context.

Polyphemus’ Eyepatch profile Josh Zuckerman-Erd // CriticalEDH profile

Game filter

Shared W-L-D stats can be limited to Elo-worthy events with 30+ players; Elo rankings are unchanged.

Show 30+ player games only

Polyphemus’ Eyepatch Record

4-2-1

Perspective: Polyphemus’ Eyepatch

Josh Zuckerman-Erd // CriticalEDH Record

2-4-1

Perspective: Josh Zuckerman-Erd // CriticalEDH

Shared Games

7

Latest Meeting

Jun 20, 2026

First Meeting

Dec 27, 2025

Polyphemus’ Eyepatch Commander Stats

Commander	Games	W-L-D
Unknown Commander	7	4-2-1

Josh Zuckerman-Erd // CriticalEDH Commander Stats

Commander	Games	W-L-D
Unknown Commander	6	2-3-1
Tayam, Luminous Enigma	1	0-1-0

Chronological Game History

Sorted newest first. Expand a game to see the full pod and winner highlight.

LEVEL SEVEN'S WEEKLY CEDH EVENT

Draw

Jun 20, 2026Round 3Table 2Polyphemus’ Eyepatch : Seat 1, Unknown CommanderJosh Zuckerman-Erd // CriticalEDH: Seat 2, Unknown Commander

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	Polyphemus’ Eyepatch	Unknown Commander	DRAW

Level 7 Games Engelwood Cedh But its Friday The 13th Again

Josh Zuckerman-Erd // CriticalEDH won

Mar 14, 2026Round 3Table 5Polyphemus’ Eyepatch : Seat 4, Unknown CommanderJosh Zuckerman-Erd // CriticalEDH: Seat 1, Unknown Commander

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	Josh Zuckerman-Erd // CriticalEDH	Unknown Commander	WINNER
2	Kyle Haas	Unknown Commander	LOSS
3	[CHUDS] Nathan Shiflet	Unknown Commander	LOSS
4	Polyphemus’ Eyepatch	Unknown Commander	LOSS

LEVEL SEVEN'S WEEKLY CEDH EVENT

Polyphemus’ Eyepatch won

Mar 8, 2026Round 2Table 3Polyphemus’ Eyepatch : Seat 1, Unknown CommanderJosh Zuckerman-Erd // CriticalEDH: Seat 4, Unknown Commander

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	Polyphemus’ Eyepatch	Unknown Commander	WINNER
2	Titus Timely Talker (EBAM)	Unknown Commander	LOSS
3	Cortes	Unknown Commander	LOSS
4	Josh Zuckerman-Erd // CriticalEDH	Unknown Commander	LOSS

Level 7 Games Cedh Engelwood 1/30/26

Polyphemus’ Eyepatch won

Jan 31, 2026Round 3Table 7Polyphemus’ Eyepatch : Seat 1, Unknown CommanderJosh Zuckerman-Erd // CriticalEDH: Seat 2, Unknown Commander

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	Polyphemus’ Eyepatch	Unknown Commander	WINNER
2	Josh Zuckerman-Erd // CriticalEDH	Unknown Commander	LOSS
3	[RNCH]Jeremy Barton	Animar, Soul of Elements	LOSS

Level Seven Englewood Weekly

Josh Zuckerman-Erd // CriticalEDH won

Jan 10, 2026Top 10Table 2Polyphemus’ Eyepatch : Seat 2, Unknown CommanderJosh Zuckerman-Erd // CriticalEDH: Seat 3, Unknown Commander

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	Cortes	Unknown Commander	LOSS
2	Polyphemus’ Eyepatch	Unknown Commander	LOSS
3	Josh Zuckerman-Erd // CriticalEDH	Unknown Commander	WINNER
4	Isaac Medlin	Tymna the Weaver / Thrasios, Triton Hero	LOSS

level 7 Cedh weekly englewood but its 2026

Polyphemus’ Eyepatch won

Jan 3, 2026Round 3Table 4Polyphemus’ Eyepatch : Seat 1, Unknown CommanderJosh Zuckerman-Erd // CriticalEDH: Seat 4, Unknown Commander

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	Polyphemus’ Eyepatch	Unknown Commander	WINNER
2	Kai Masuchika	Unknown Commander	LOSS
3	Stephen Walsh	Unknown Commander	LOSS
4	Josh Zuckerman-Erd // CriticalEDH	Unknown Commander	LOSS

Level 7 Cedh but after Christmas 12/26

Polyphemus’ Eyepatch won

Dec 27, 2025Top 4Table 1Polyphemus’ Eyepatch : Seat 2, Unknown CommanderJosh Zuckerman-Erd // CriticalEDH: Seat 1, Tayam, Luminous Enigma

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	Josh Zuckerman-Erd // CriticalEDH	Tayam, Luminous Enigma	LOSS
2	Polyphemus’ Eyepatch	Unknown Commander	WINNER
3	[CRASH] Anthony Warren	Unknown Commander	LOSS
4	Dan Montes	Unknown Commander	LOSS