Loading player profile…
Loading commander matchups…
Loading achievements…
Data provided by TopDeck.gg
← Back to player profile

Brennan vs Carter John Barthelmes

Shared game history, mirrored head-to-head record, and full pod context.

Brennan profileCarter John Barthelmes profile
Brennan Record
2-1-5
Perspective: Brennan
Carter John Barthelmes Record
0-3-5
Perspective: Carter John Barthelmes
Shared Games
8
Latest Meeting
Feb 6, 2026
First Meeting
Sep 5, 2025
Brennan Commander Stats
CommanderGamesW-L-D
Unknown Commander82-1-5
Carter John Barthelmes Commander Stats
CommanderGamesW-L-D
Unknown Commander80-3-5
Chronological Game History

Sorted newest first. Expand a game to see the full pod and winner highlight.

Casual Commander
Brennan won
Feb 6, 2026Round 2Table 2CALIFORNIABrennan: Seat 2, Unknown CommanderCarter John Barthelmes : Seat 3, Unknown Commander
SeatPlayerCommanderResult
1CarterUnknown CommanderLOSS
2
Brennan
Unknown Commander
WINNER
3Carter John Barthelmes Unknown CommanderLOSS
4Ari moserUnknown CommanderLOSS
Magic on the Mountain - December 2025 cEDH @Windfall Games
Donald Bell won
Dec 5, 2025Round 2Table 2CALIFORNIABrennan: Seat 1, Unknown CommanderCarter John Barthelmes : Seat 3, Unknown Commander
SeatPlayerCommanderResult
1BrennanUnknown CommanderLOSS
2Donald BellUnknown CommanderWINNER
3Carter John Barthelmes Unknown CommanderLOSS
Windfall Games Commander Party
Draw
Oct 3, 2025Round 2Table 3CALIFORNIABrennan: Seat 1, Unknown CommanderCarter John Barthelmes : Seat 2, Unknown Commander
SeatPlayerCommanderResult
1BrennanUnknown CommanderDRAW
2Carter John Barthelmes Unknown CommanderDRAW
3Jonathan HashimotoUnknown CommanderDRAW
Friday Night Magic at Windfall Games
Draw
Sep 12, 2025Round 1Table 1CALIFORNIABrennan: Seat 4, Unknown CommanderCarter John Barthelmes : Seat 2, Unknown Commander
SeatPlayerCommanderResult
1Logan RenehanUnknown CommanderDRAW
2Carter John Barthelmes Unknown CommanderDRAW
3Darren RobisonUnknown CommanderDRAW
4BrennanUnknown CommanderDRAW
Friday Night Magic at Windfall Games
Draw
Sep 12, 2025Round 2Table 1CALIFORNIABrennan: Seat 1, Unknown CommanderCarter John Barthelmes : Seat 3, Unknown Commander
SeatPlayerCommanderResult
1BrennanUnknown CommanderDRAW
2Gwendolyn HashimotoUnknown CommanderDRAW
3Carter John Barthelmes Unknown CommanderDRAW
4Michael C DillenbeckUnknown CommanderDRAW
Windfall Games Commander Party
Draw
Sep 5, 2025Round 1Table 2CALIFORNIABrennan: Seat 2, Unknown CommanderCarter John Barthelmes : Seat 4, Unknown Commander
SeatPlayerCommanderResult
1Jonathan HashimotoUnknown CommanderDRAW
2BrennanUnknown CommanderDRAW
3Logan RenehanUnknown CommanderDRAW
4Carter John Barthelmes Unknown CommanderDRAW
Windfall Games Commander Party
Draw
Sep 5, 2025Round 2Table 1CALIFORNIABrennan: Seat 1, Unknown CommanderCarter John Barthelmes : Seat 3, Unknown Commander
SeatPlayerCommanderResult
1BrennanUnknown CommanderDRAW
2MattUnknown CommanderDRAW
3Carter John Barthelmes Unknown CommanderDRAW
4Jonathan HashimotoUnknown CommanderDRAW
Windfall Games Commander Party
Brennan won
Sep 5, 2025Round 3Table 2CALIFORNIABrennan: Seat 3, Unknown CommanderCarter John Barthelmes : Seat 2, Unknown Commander
SeatPlayerCommanderResult
1Logan RenehanUnknown CommanderLOSS
2Carter John Barthelmes Unknown CommanderLOSS
3BrennanUnknown CommanderWINNER