← Back to player profile
Andy Buttons(chubby) vs Nicholas Roy
Shared game history, mirrored head-to-head record, and full pod context.
Andy Buttons(chubby) Record
2-10-2
Perspective: Andy Buttons(chubby)
Nicholas Roy Record
0-12-2
Perspective: Nicholas Roy
Shared Games
14
Latest Meeting
Jan 31, 2026
First Meeting
Aug 31, 2025
Andy Buttons(chubby) Commander Stats
| Commander | Games | W-L-D |
|---|---|---|
| Unknown Commander | 14 | 2-10-2 |
Nicholas Roy Commander Stats
| Commander | Games | W-L-D |
|---|---|---|
| Unknown Commander | 14 | 0-12-2 |
Chronological Game History
Sorted newest first. Expand a game to see the full pod and winner highlight.
CriticalEDH February 2026 LeagueHelixsnake35 wonJan 31, 2026Round 1Table 1451Andy Buttons(chubby) : Seat 4, Unknown CommanderNicholas Roy : Seat 2, Unknown Commander
CriticalEDH February 2026 League
Helixsnake35 won
Jan 31, 2026Round 1Table 1451Andy Buttons(chubby) : Seat 4, Unknown CommanderNicholas Roy : Seat 2, Unknown Commander
| Seat | Player | Commander | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Helixsnake35 | Unknown Commander | WINNER |
| 2 | Nicholas Roy | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 3 | Gavin Berkey | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 4 | Andy Buttons(chubby) | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
CriticalEDH November 2025 LeagueMax Safran wonOct 31, 2025Round 1Table 1260Andy Buttons(chubby) : Seat 4, Unknown CommanderNicholas Roy : Seat 2, Unknown Commander
CriticalEDH November 2025 League
Max Safran won
Oct 31, 2025Round 1Table 1260Andy Buttons(chubby) : Seat 4, Unknown CommanderNicholas Roy : Seat 2, Unknown Commander
| Seat | Player | Commander | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Max Safran | Unknown Commander | WINNER |
| 2 | Nicholas Roy | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 3 | James Daniell | Krark, the Thumbless / Tymna the Weaver | LOSS |
| 4 | Andy Buttons(chubby) | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
CriticalEDH November 2025 LeagueBradley Hart wonOct 31, 2025Round 1Table 1271Andy Buttons(chubby) : Seat 1, Unknown CommanderNicholas Roy : Seat 3, Unknown Commander
CriticalEDH November 2025 League
Bradley Hart won
Oct 31, 2025Round 1Table 1271Andy Buttons(chubby) : Seat 1, Unknown CommanderNicholas Roy : Seat 3, Unknown Commander
| Seat | Player | Commander | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Andy Buttons(chubby) | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 2 | Bradley Hart | Unknown Commander | WINNER |
| 3 | Nicholas Roy | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 4 | Connor Guinness | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
CriticalEDH November 2025 LeagueDrawOct 31, 2025Round 1Table 1278Andy Buttons(chubby) : Seat 4, Unknown CommanderNicholas Roy : Seat 2, Unknown Commander
CriticalEDH November 2025 League
Draw
Oct 31, 2025Round 1Table 1278Andy Buttons(chubby) : Seat 4, Unknown CommanderNicholas Roy : Seat 2, Unknown Commander
| Seat | Player | Commander | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | [LPW] DameGPT | Unknown Commander | DRAW |
| 2 | Nicholas Roy | Unknown Commander | DRAW |
| 3 | Biscuit | Unknown Commander | DRAW |
| 4 | Andy Buttons(chubby) | Unknown Commander | DRAW |
CriticalEDH November 2025 LeagueJJ//raGemaGe_MTG wonOct 31, 2025Round 1Table 1458Andy Buttons(chubby) : Seat 4, Unknown CommanderNicholas Roy : Seat 2, Unknown Commander
CriticalEDH November 2025 League
JJ//raGemaGe_MTG won
Oct 31, 2025Round 1Table 1458Andy Buttons(chubby) : Seat 4, Unknown CommanderNicholas Roy : Seat 2, Unknown Commander
| Seat | Player | Commander | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Jerry Rowland | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 2 | Nicholas Roy | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 3 | JJ//raGemaGe_MTG | Unknown Commander | WINNER |
| 4 | Andy Buttons(chubby) | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
CriticalEDH November 2025 LeagueAndy Buttons(chubby) wonOct 31, 2025Round 1Table 1795Andy Buttons(chubby) : Seat 3, Unknown CommanderNicholas Roy : Seat 2, Unknown Commander
CriticalEDH November 2025 League
Andy Buttons(chubby) won
Oct 31, 2025Round 1Table 1795Andy Buttons(chubby) : Seat 3, Unknown CommanderNicholas Roy : Seat 2, Unknown Commander
| Seat | Player | Commander | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Tilly | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 2 | Nicholas Roy | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 3 | Andy Buttons(chubby) | Unknown Commander | WINNER |
| 4 | Matt Arciuolo | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
CriticalEDH October 2025 LeagueDexter Idzikowski wonSep 30, 2025Round 1Table 293Andy Buttons(chubby) : Seat 1, Unknown CommanderNicholas Roy : Seat 2, Unknown Commander
CriticalEDH October 2025 League
Dexter Idzikowski won
Sep 30, 2025Round 1Table 293Andy Buttons(chubby) : Seat 1, Unknown CommanderNicholas Roy : Seat 2, Unknown Commander
| Seat | Player | Commander | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Andy Buttons(chubby) | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 2 | Nicholas Roy | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 3 | Dexter Idzikowski | Rograkh, Son of Rohgahh / Silas Renn, Seeker Adept | WINNER |
| 4 | Jase Sanders | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
CriticalEDH October 2025 LeagueJase Sanders wonSep 30, 2025Round 1Table 297Andy Buttons(chubby) : Seat 2, Unknown CommanderNicholas Roy : Seat 4, Unknown Commander
CriticalEDH October 2025 League
Jase Sanders won
Sep 30, 2025Round 1Table 297Andy Buttons(chubby) : Seat 2, Unknown CommanderNicholas Roy : Seat 4, Unknown Commander
| Seat | Player | Commander | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Jase Sanders | Unknown Commander | WINNER |
| 2 | Andy Buttons(chubby) | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 3 | jadyn stewart- cantin | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 4 | Nicholas Roy | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
CriticalEDH October 2025 LeagueJase Sanders wonSep 30, 2025Round 1Table 299Andy Buttons(chubby) : Seat 1, Unknown CommanderNicholas Roy : Seat 3, Unknown Commander
CriticalEDH October 2025 League
Jase Sanders won
Sep 30, 2025Round 1Table 299Andy Buttons(chubby) : Seat 1, Unknown CommanderNicholas Roy : Seat 3, Unknown Commander
| Seat | Player | Commander | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Andy Buttons(chubby) | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 2 | jadyn stewart- cantin | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 3 | Nicholas Roy | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 4 | Jase Sanders | Unknown Commander | WINNER |
CriticalEDH October 2025 LeagueAndy Buttons(chubby) wonSep 30, 2025Round 1Table 398Andy Buttons(chubby) : Seat 1, Unknown CommanderNicholas Roy : Seat 3, Unknown Commander
CriticalEDH October 2025 League
Andy Buttons(chubby) won
Sep 30, 2025Round 1Table 398Andy Buttons(chubby) : Seat 1, Unknown CommanderNicholas Roy : Seat 3, Unknown Commander
| Seat | Player | Commander | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Andy Buttons(chubby) | Unknown Commander | WINNER |
| 2 | Rourke Moran | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 3 | Nicholas Roy | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 4 | Rodrigo I. | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
CriticalEDH October 2025 LeagueChristian Mukai wonSep 30, 2025Round 1Table 407Andy Buttons(chubby) : Seat 2, Unknown CommanderNicholas Roy : Seat 1, Unknown Commander
CriticalEDH October 2025 League
Christian Mukai won
Sep 30, 2025Round 1Table 407Andy Buttons(chubby) : Seat 2, Unknown CommanderNicholas Roy : Seat 1, Unknown Commander
| Seat | Player | Commander | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Nicholas Roy | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 2 | Andy Buttons(chubby) | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 3 | Christian Mukai | Unknown Commander | WINNER |
| 4 | Rourke Moran | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
CriticalEDH October 2025 LeagueSmalls [Monolith] wonSep 30, 2025Round 1Table 1772Andy Buttons(chubby) : Seat 3, Unknown CommanderNicholas Roy : Seat 4, Unknown Commander
CriticalEDH October 2025 League
Smalls [Monolith] won
Sep 30, 2025Round 1Table 1772Andy Buttons(chubby) : Seat 3, Unknown CommanderNicholas Roy : Seat 4, Unknown Commander
| Seat | Player | Commander | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Smalls [Monolith] | Unknown Commander | WINNER |
| 2 | Josh [SOCC] | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 3 | Andy Buttons(chubby) | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 4 | Nicholas Roy | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
CriticalEDH October 2025 LeagueDrawSep 30, 2025Round 1Table 1836Andy Buttons(chubby) : Seat 2, Unknown CommanderNicholas Roy : Seat 4, Unknown Commander
CriticalEDH October 2025 League
Draw
Sep 30, 2025Round 1Table 1836Andy Buttons(chubby) : Seat 2, Unknown CommanderNicholas Roy : Seat 4, Unknown Commander
| Seat | Player | Commander | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Last Seat | Unknown Commander | DRAW |
| 2 | Andy Buttons(chubby) | Unknown Commander | DRAW |
| 3 | Max C (RND) | Unknown Commander | DRAW |
| 4 | Nicholas Roy | Unknown Commander | DRAW |
CriticalEDH September 2025 LeagueTilly wonAug 31, 2025Round 1Table 1726Andy Buttons(chubby) : Seat 2, Unknown CommanderNicholas Roy : Seat 3, Unknown Commander
CriticalEDH September 2025 League
Tilly won
Aug 31, 2025Round 1Table 1726Andy Buttons(chubby) : Seat 2, Unknown CommanderNicholas Roy : Seat 3, Unknown Commander
| Seat | Player | Commander | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Tilly | Unknown Commander | WINNER |
| 2 | Andy Buttons(chubby) | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 3 | Nicholas Roy | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 4 | Sean Barmapov | Unknown Commander | LOSS |